Who has The Hamptons Best Pizza?

Hamptons Best Pizza (2025 Update)

Pizza. It’s the ultimate comfort food, the go-to for gatherings, beach nights, and casual Friday dinners. But let’s be honest—everyone has strong opinions about what makes the perfect slice. For some, it’s all about the crust. Others swear by the sauce. And for cheese lovers? Well, cheese is life.

As for me? I need the trifecta: crust, sauce, and cheese in perfect balance. I lean toward a crisp, thin crust—it lets the toppings shine without being overwhelmed by dough. I’m not a fan of overloaded tomato sauce (you know the kind that makes the cheese slip off with every bite). Toppings? I love it all—fresh basil and mozzarella, pepperoni with a little char, sausage and peppers, mushrooms… you name it.

Now the question everyone asks me:
Who has the best pizza in the Hamptons in 2025?

While some old-school pizza lovers still argue that nothing compares to a slice from Queens or Manhattan (and yes, my husband still mourns the legendary Gloria’s Pizza in Flushing), I think we’ve got some real contenders right here on the East End. From family-run joints to wood-fired ovens and elevated gourmet pies, the Hamptons has serious pizza game.

This list is curated based on personal visits, recommendations from locals, and buzz from social media, Yelp, and Google. My criteria? Traditional New York–style pizza, flavor-packed crust, balanced sauce, quality cheese, fresh toppings—and of course, taste.

⸻

Hamptons Mouthpiece Picks for Best Pizza (2025 Edition)

1. Fini Pizza – Amagansett
   Thin Crust perfection. I’m in love with the White Cheese pie with lemon zest and hot honey on the side. Yum! It is a bit expensive, I paid $39 for this pie, but it was worth it.
2. P&G Pizza & Deli – Southampton
   Unassuming, reliable, and delicious. This classic spot hits all the right notes, especially when you want a classic NY slice.
3. Slice – Shelter Island
   Worth the trip across the water. Creative toppings, fresh ingredients, and a laid-back island feel.
4. La Capannina – Wainscott
   Perfectly crisp crust, simple flavors, and fast service. Grab a pie and head to the beach.
5. La Parmigiana – Southampton
   A Hamptons staple. Their traditional pies are hearty and satisfying every single time.
6. Sam’s Restaurant – East Hampton
   Old-school Italian charm with consistently good pizza. Bonus: full Italian menu if you’re dining in.
7. Francesca’s Restaurant & Pizzeria – Hampton Bays
   Reliable neighborhood favorite. Great for families and large orders.
8. Tonino’s Pizza – Westhampton Beach
   Great for a casual slice or a full pie. Loved for their generous toppings and quick service.
9. Springs Pizza – Springs
   This hidden gem has a loyal following. Try the white pie!
10. Pizza Pizza in Sag Harbor, this is a new pizza place located inside Cluckman’s, I really enjoyed a regular slice of pizza, I thought the sauce & cheese were delicious. I did find it to be a bit pricey but definitely less than some other nearby places. My favorite was the white cheese pizza with mushrooms. Finally a place where you can just get a regular slice of pizza in Sag Harbor.

⸻

Got a favorite that’s not on the list?

Email me at hamptonsmouthpiece@gmail.com with your suggestion. If I try it and love it, it might just make the next edition—with a shoutout on all my social channels!

Because let’s be real—life’s too short for bad pizza. And in the Hamptons, we deserve the best.