One woman’s journey through grief inspires Let’s Holiday in Sag Harbor, bringing an entire village together to celebrate generosity, community, and the true meaning of the holiday season.

There is something magical about Sag Harbor during the holidays, and this year, Let’s Holiday in Sag Harbor  promises to make the season even more special. The summer crowds have disappeared, Main Street feels a little more intimate, and finding a parking space no longer requires the patience of a saint. Now that’s something worth celebrating!

This year, something especially meaningful is happening. On Tuesday, December 15, from 4 to 8 p.m., Let’s Holiday in Sag Harbor will bring our village together for an evening of music, festive storefronts, shopping, dining, and good old-fashioned community spirit.

Let's Holiday in Sag Harbor, an ai image of how we envision Sag Harbor to look with All white lights for the Holiday season 2026.
original photo Vanessa Leggard, AI generated to add lights at dusk

I recently sat down with Susie Franklin of the historic American Hotel in Sag Harbor to talk about the celebration. What began as a conversation about holiday decorations quickly became something much deeper: a story about love, loss, gratitude, and the extraordinary people who call Sag Harbor home.

 Susie Franklin, Proprietor of the American Hotel,  Let's Holiday in Sag Harbor

Susie’s husband, Ted Conklin, who operated the American Hotel for 54 years, passed away on February 1. Following his death, neighbors organized a gathering to welcome her into her new role, even serenading her with a personalized rendition of “Hello, Dolly!”

“They wrapped their arms around me, and I just felt I had to give back in some way,” she told me.

That simple act of kindness inspired an idea. What if every storefront on Main Street illuminated its windows for the holidays? That vision became Let’s Holiday in Sag Harbor, a celebration bringing together schools, religious organizations, merchants, musicians, and volunteers.

“It’s exploded,” Susie said, clearly delighted by the overwhelming response.

The best part? This inaugural celebration began without a formal budget or corporate sponsors. People simply offered their time, talents, and creativity, proving that community spirit doesn’t always require a big checkbook.

That’s Sag Harbor at its finest.

Let’s Holiday in Sag Harbor will feature performances by Sag Harbor Elementary and Pierson School, Temple Adas Israel, the Eastville AME Gospel Choir, Victorian Carolers, and Roman Roth with the Christ Church Choir. Local businesses will welcome neighbors, while holiday displays transform the village into something straight out of a Christmas movie.

Even the American Hotel is getting a festive makeover, with designer Hank Stampfl helping transform the historic property into a holiday destination.

American Hotel in Sag Harbor, Let's Holiday in Sag Harbor

Yet Susie’s vision goes far beyond decorations.

On December 1, at 6:30 p.m., the community will gather at Old Whalers’ Church for The Light Within, an evening honoring the volunteers who make Sag Harbor special.

The Light within, Tuesday December 1st at the Old Whalers Church,  Let's Holiday in Sag Harbor

“It’s the people,” Susie told me. “We just have a community of givers, and it’s like I’ve never seen before.”

She’s talking about everyone, from firefighters and generous donors to neighbors who shovel sidewalks or quietly help someone struggling. That spirit of generosity is exactly what Let’s Holiday in Sag Harbor hopes to celebrate.

That sentiment resonates with me. When my family moved to Sag Harbor in 2001, we knew very few people. Raising two young daughters in a new community wasn’t always easy, yet Sag Harbor eventually became the place they proudly call home.

That experience inspired me to create the @sagharbor platform. I wanted people to understand that our village doesn’t disappear after Labor Day. Families live here, businesses depend on year-round customers, and our community deserves attention in February just as much as July.

Susie understands that responsibility. When we discussed the importance of supporting local businesses, her response was simple.

Ted kept the American Hotel open through difficult winter months, sometimes sacrificing profits to retain employees and preserve the exceptional service that made the hotel a landmark. Some employees have worked there for decades, and that loyalty speaks volumes.

Susie intends to preserve his legacy while creating new opportunities for residents to gather during the quieter months.

That’s another reason Let’s Holiday in Sag Harbor feels so meaningful. The celebration takes place on a Tuesday, not a Saturday, and I love that! It’s a reminder that Sag Harbor isn’t just a weekend destination. It’s a year-round community filled with people who live, work, raise families, and support one another. This evening is about bringing those neighbors together, supporting our local businesses, and celebrating the village we’re proud to call home.

And everyone is invited.

Mark Your Calendar 🎄Let’s Holiday in Sag Harbor

  • November 28, 4:15–5:30 p.m.: Light Up the Harbor, featuring The Dickens Carolers and the annual tree lighting at Long Wharf.
  • November 28–December 31: Best Holiday Window Display Contest, with public voting by QR code.
  • December 1, 6:30 p.m.: The Light Within, honoring community volunteers at Old Whalers’ Church.
  • December 15, 4–8 p.m.: Let’s Holiday in Sag Harbor, with music, carolers, shopping, dining, and festive activities throughout the village.

Let’s Holiday in Sag Harbor is truly a community effort, inspired by Susie Franklin of the American Hotel and brought to life in partnership with the Sag Harbor Chamber of Commerce, which is funding the white holiday lights along Main Street and Long Wharf. Behind the scenes, Polly Kruse, Marilyn Holstein, Penny Siebert, Mark Lubell, Jesse Matsuoka, Tia Greene-Granger and myself along with local merchants and volunteers, have contributed their time, creativity, and enthusiasm. It’s a beautiful reminder of what can happen when a community comes together with one shared goal: celebrating the village we love.

As our conversation ended, Susie shared how the love of the American Hotel family and the surrounding community has helped sustain her following Ted’s death.

Those words stayed with me. Sometimes the greatest holiday gift isn’t something wrapped beneath a Christmas tree. It’s knowing that when life changes unexpectedly, your community will show up, embrace you, and remind you that you’re not alone.

That’s what makes Let’s Holiday in Sag Harbor so much more than a festive evening. It’s a celebration of the people, relationships, and generosity that make our village feel like home.

Real Talk. Real People. Real Communities.

This holiday season, let’s do more than admire the lights. Let’s support our local businesses, thank our volunteers, reconnect with neighbors, and celebrate the village we love. After all, the real magic of Sag Harbor has never been about the beautiful storefronts. It’s always been about the people behind them.

What makes Sag Harbor feel like home to you? Share your favorite holiday memory or give a shout-out to someone who makes our community special in the comments.

Author

Vanessa Leggard Wife. Girl mom. Digital storyteller. Community connector. I’m the founder of Hamptons Mouthpiece, a lifestyle digital publication delivering real talk from real people — covering women’s health, wellness, food, human rights, and events from NYC to the East End of Long Island. Whether I’m spotlighting local voices, stirring up bold conversations, or sharing stories that matter, I’m here to inform, inspire, and amplify. I’m also a seasoned social media strategist, content creator, and co-owner of Photography by Kurt. Everything I do is rooted in purpose, creativity, and a deep love for the communities I serve.

Comments are closed.